Replacing
popular conventional engine and driveline lubricants with AMSOIL synthetic
lubricants in Class 8 diesel-fueled vehicles increases fuel mileage up to
8.2% according to the findings of an
independent test facility.
Fuel accounts for roughly 37 percent of Class 8 truck operating
expenses, and reducing fuel expenses is a top priority for truck operators.
Independent laboratory testing shows AMSOIL
Series 3000 Synthetic 5W-30 Heavy
Duty Diesel Oil in the engine and AMSOIL synthetics in the drivetrain
provide up to 8.2 percent more miles-per-gallon than other popular lubricants
provide.
Introduction
At the request of AMSOIL INC., an independent research institute conducted a
month-long test comparing the fuel consumption of Class 8 diesel trucks
equipped with AMSOIL synthetic lubricants to Class 8 diesel trucks equipped with
conventional lubricants.
The research institute used the SAE J1321 Joint TMC/SAE Fuel
Consumption Test Procedure-Type II, an industry standard test procedure for
comparing in-service fuel consumption of a vehicle operated under two
conditions, one with the control lubricants in place, the other with the test
lubricants in place.
Vehicles and Route
The three test and one control vehicles were 1995 International Model 9200
truck-tractors with Cummins M-11 engines (rated at 350 hp at 1600 rpm), Fuller
RTXF 14710B transmissions, Eaton Model DS/RS 404 drive axles (3.90 ratio),
11R-24.5 low-profile tires and new oil and air filters. All four vehicles had
been operated between 250,000 and 285,000 miles prior to the study.
The trucks were equipped with auxiliary weigh fuel tanks and
quick disconnect couplings to facilitate accurate data gathering. Each truck
pulled a 45-foot long flatbed trailer equipped with 11R-24.5 low-profile tires
and loaded with concrete blocks so that the gross vehicle weight (GVW) of each
vehicle was 75,550 ±100 lbs.
The test route represented typical long-haul interstate highway
operations, with asphalt road surfaces and generally flat terrain. The low
traffic density route covered a total of 40 miles with a 20-mile southbound
segment and the return north-bound segment. Fuel consumption was measured
separately for each direction.
Lubricants and Fuels
The control lubricants were Shell Rotella T 15W-40 for the engines, Quaker State
SAE 90 for the transmissions and Citco 85W-140 for the drive axles. The control
truck used the control lubricants for all driving segments and the test trucks
used the control lubricants for their baseline segments.
The test lubricants were
AMSOIL Series 3000
Synthetic 5W-30 Heavy Duty Diesel Oil for the engines,
AMSOIL Series 2000 Synthetic
20W-50 Racing Oil for the transmissions and
AMSOIL Series 2000
Synthetic 75W-90 Gear Lube for the drive axles. The test vehicles used the
test lubricants for their test segments.
All vehicles used Exxon No. 2 diesel fuel dispensed from the
same storage tank for all driving segments.
Procedure
Each test vehicle ran a baseline segment, in which the truck was equipped with
the control lubricants, and three test segments, in which it was equipped with
test lubricants. The control vehicle concurrently ran each driving segment using
control lubricants.
Conditions including speed, tire pressure, headlight and fan use
and window openings were held constant between all vehicles in each driving
segment. Finally, testing proceeded only if wind direction, wind speed and
temperature were within test parameters.
Results
The weight of fuel consumed by each test vehicle and the weight of fuel consumed
by the control vehicle in each driving segment were used to determine the
percentage of fuel saved and the percentage fuel efficiency improvement obtained
by the test lubricants. Results outside 2 percent of the norm were discarded.
Findings
The vehicles equipped with AMSOIL synthetic lubricants in the engines,
transmissions and drive axles demonstrated up to an 8.2 percent increase in
miles per gallon (mpg) over the mpg obtained by the vehicles equipped with the
control lubricants.
Discussion
Test conditions were held close to ideal for maximum fuel economy. In many
instances of less-than-ideal conditions, the synthetic test lubricants would
have provided even more fuel economy improvement. For example, synthetics’
superior cold temperature fluidity provides a larger proportion of fuel savings
in cold operating conditions.
Additionally, while the present study did not include analysis
of wear control, wear control is an important issue with low viscosity
lubricants and one fully addressed by AMSOIL through additional testing.
Traditionally, the benefit of improved fuel economy provided by
low viscosity lubricants is offset by a penalty in wear control. Such is not the
case with Series 2000 and 3000 lubricants, as evidenced by Four-Ball Wear
testing conducted by an independent laboratory (results shown on product labels)
and a growing body of demonstration and on-road data.
For
example, an ongoing fleet demonstration is providing evidence of the excellent
wear control of Series 3000. Since January 1996, AMSOIL and a northern tier
trucking fleet have been conducting a demonstration using Series 3000 in the
1996 Cummins N-14 ESP3 engines of five 1996 Kenworth class 8 trucks.
The trucks traveled 125,000 miles with-out an oil change and the
rate of wear metal generation found in used Series 3000 samples was lower than
that found in used control oil, Pennzoil Long Life 15W-40, which is changed at
20,000-mile intervals.
Additionally, the viscometrics of the AMSOIL fluids provide a
wear control benefit in cold temperature applications since low viscosity fluids
flow more freely in cold temperatures than high viscosity fluids do. Oils that
flow easily in cold temperatures provide faster post-startup wear protection in
cold engines than do less fluid oils. They also provide easier starting and
reduced battery drain.
Finally, AMSOIL product users are protected by the AMSOIL
warranty, which, unlike warranties offered by other oil companies, is not
limited by time or mileage and does not require user registration and approval.
Conclusion
AMSOIL synthetic engine, transmission and drive axle lubricants provide a safe
and effective means to significantly increase class 8 truck fuel economy.
AMSOIL Series 3000 Synthetic 5W-30 Heavy Duty Diesel Motor Oil
provides better wear protection than these popular high viscosity diesel oils.
In fact, independent testing showed the high-viscosity oils tested produced wear
scars up to 45 percent larger than that of Series 3000.
What Does a Savings of 8.2% Mean?
Imagine a fleet of 100 class 8 vehicles running an average 120,000 miles per
year at an average 6.5 mpg with diesel fuel at $1.35 a gallon. The fleet spends
$2,492,308 on fuel annually. Now imagine the fleet uses AMSOIL products and
improves its miles-per-gallon by 8.2 percent. The fleet now spends $2,303,427 on
fuel annually.
That’s a savings of $188,881.
That money could buy a year’s worth of AMSOIL synthetic lubricants for the
fleet plus a year’s fuel for 3 to 6 trucks – with cash left over!
CUMMINS M-11 ENGINE
Sump capacity: 9 gallons
|
With oil changes at 120,000-mile intervals |
|
900 gal AMSOIL Series 3000 Synthetic 5W-30 Heavy Duty Diesel Oil |
| ($18.35/gal
in 275-gal totes or 55-gal drums) |
$16,515 |
|
With oil changes at 60,000-mile intervals |
| 1800 gal @
$18.35/gal |
$33,030 |
|
With oil changes at 40,000-mile intervals |
| 2700 gal @
$18.35/gal |
$49,545 |
|
With oil changes at 20,000-mile intervals |
| 5400 gal @
$18.35/gal |
$99,090 |
FULLER RTXF-14710B TRANSMISSION
Sump: 25.5 pints (3.2 gal)
One fluid fill
|
320 gal Series 2000 20W-50 Synthetic Racing
Oil |
| ($18.35/gal
in 275-gal totes or 55-gal drums) |
$5,872 |
EATON MODEL DS 404 DRIVE AXLES
Sump: 63 pints (7.9 gal)
One fluid fill
|
790 gal Series 2000 75W-90 Synthetic Gear
Lube |
| ($19.80/gal
in 275-gal totes or 55-gal drums) |
$15,642 |
| TOTAL
LUBE COSTS |
|
| At 20,000-mile oil
drain intervals |
$120,604 |
| At 40,000-mile oil
drain intervals |
$71,059 |
| At 60,000-mile oil
drain intervals |
$54,544 |
| At 120,000-mile oil
drain intervals |
$38,029 |
After deducting the annual AMSOIL lube cost from $188,881,
the fleet still has between $68,277 and $150,852 – enough to buy a year’s worth
of fuel for 3 to 6 trucks – with cash left over!
This shows the value of using extended drains!